Implantation of customized 3-D printed titanium prosthesis in limb salvage surgery: a case series and review of the literature
- Hongbin Fan†1,
- Jun Fu†1,
- Xiangdong Li1,
- Yanjun Pei1,
- Xiaokang Li1,
- Guoxian Pei1 and
- Zheng Guo1Email author
© Fan et al. 2015
Received: 23 June 2015
Accepted: 26 October 2015
Published: 4 November 2015
Although modular prosthesis is commercially available to meet requirements in most limb salvage surgeries, customized prosthesis is still needed. In contrast to traditional complicated procedures, rapid prototyping (RP) technique can directly manufacture customized titanium prosthesis. The objectives of this study were to describe the workflow of this technique and show the follow-up results of patients.
Three patients with clavicle Ewing’s sarcoma (ES), scapular ES, and pelvic chondrosarcoma (CS) were scanned by computer tomography (CT). The images were segmented and reconstructed for preoperative planning and prosthesis design. Then, the data of prosthesis were imported into an electron beam melting system to manufacture implants. These three patients received prosthesis implantation after tumor excision. They were followed up to evaluate survival rate, functional outcome, and complications.
All patients were alive with no evidence of disease. The Musculoskeletal Tumor Society (MSTS) scores were 93, 73, and 90 % for patients with clavicle ES, scapular ES, and pelvic CS, respectively. No surgical complications including limb length discrepancy, screw loosening, and implant breakage were observed in current study.
Electron beam melting (EBM) is a useful method to directly manufacture customized titanium prostheses. It might improve the effectiveness of limb salvage surgery for sarcomas in unusual sites.
KeywordsRapid prototyping Prosthesis Titanium Electron beam melting
In the past several decades, various reconstructions including autograft, allograft, and customized or modular prosthesis have been extensively used for limb salvages . Each has its own advantages and limitations. Autograft has superior healing capability due to excellent osteoconductive and osteoinductive properties. However, it requires invasive collection and supply is limited . Allograft can supply an immediate structural support as well as an anchor for reattachment of ligament and muscle. The associated disadvantages include possible disease transmission and slow incorporation into the host bone . In addition, both autograft and allograft have to be manually carved to precisely fit the defects. This process is usually time-consuming and laborious. Prosthesis can provide an immediate support and rapid return to weight bearing, but it is associated with frequent complications such as aseptic loosening, infection, and periprosthetic fracture . Therefore, the key issue is to weigh up the pros and cons of each reconstruction for choosing the most suitable one.
The original prosthesis is custom-made, which might cause some delay in treatment. In recent years, the modular prosthesis has been developed and extensively used in limb salvage surgeries due to being readily available. The studies indicated that the mean Musculoskeletal Tumor Society (MSTS) 93 score ranged from 57.2 to 62.0 % after modular hemi-pelvic prosthesis reconstruction [5, 6]. If customized prostheses were implanted, the patients showed similar functional scores (range 50 to 59.4 %) [7, 8]. For proximal femoral reconstruction, the estimated 5-year modular prosthesis survival rate was 90.7 % and the mean Toronto Extremity Salvage (TES) score was 61 % . On the other hand, the survival of customized prosthesis was 77 % at 10 years and 57 % at 20 years . Therefore, modular prosthesis can provide versatile reconstructions and acceptable functions for patients with sarcomas of extremity and pelvis.
However, there is no available modular prosthesis to reconstruct the clavicle, scapula, and ilium. After excisions of these bones, the optimal reconstruction has not yet been determined even though various techniques have been developed. Massive bone grafting (allograft or recycled autograft) could be an ideal biological reconstruction. Nevertheless, there remain distinct concerns including bone absorption, fracture, infection, and immune rejection [11, 12]. Prosthesis is another promising approach to restore postoperative function [13, 14]. Besides the requirement of demanding surgical techniques, the key problem of this approach is the limited availability of suitable prostheses. The most modern prosthesis is produced by machining solid titanium block, which was followed by applying different surface and geometry treatments to improve stability and osteointegration. However, none of these conventional techniques is capable of producing a completely controlled implant geometry and surface morphology in only one step.
The rapid prototyping (RP) is a process which directly generates physical objects with defined structure and shape on the basis of virtual mode data. The commonly used RP techniques include stereolithography (SLA), selective laser sintering (SLS), fused deposition modeling (FDM), laminated object manufacturing (LOM), inkjet printing, and electron beam melting (EBM). EBM is a kind of 3-D printing technique. It can be used to fabricate metallic components with complex shapes and porous structures . The irregular bones (clavicle, scapula, and ilium) have unique dimensions. Therefore, it may be a feasible solution to design customized prosthesis and manufacture it rapidly. Ti-6Al-4V (TAV) alloy scaffolds manufactured by EBM have shown complete osteointegration within 60 days in animal study . In patients with maxillofacial reconstruction, TAV implants manufactured by EBM were used to repair the zygomatico-orbital defects. The individual digital planning procedures, rapid prototyping, and titanium implants were proved to be effective . However, few studies focus specifically on the application of customized 3-D-printed TAV prosthesis in limb salvage surgeries until now. There is also a lack of information on the prosthesis survival, functional outcomes, and complications.
In this study, we designed the customized titanium prosthesis through a 3-D virtual model based on the medical image data. Then, the prosthesis was manufactured by EBM and implanted to fill the osseous defect after tumor resection. The objectives of this study were (1) to describe the workflow of this technique and (2) to show the follow-up results of patients with prosthesis. A review of the literature on this subject was also provided.
Image acquisition and prosthesis design
Firstly, all patients were scanned by computer tomography (CT) (Mutislice 64, GE Healthcare, USA). Magnified slices with 0.625 mm thickness were obtained using a soft tissue standard filter (a matrix of 512 × 512 pixels) and stored in Digital Imaging and Communication in Medicine (DICOM) format. The process of image segmentation was conducted using the Mimics software (Leuven, Belgium). The bone was isolated from other tissues and structures such as muscle, fat, skin, and metal table of CT scanner. Pseudo color image was applied on DICOM image pixel data, and segmented images were used to reconstruct a 3-D model. Because the tumor invasion usually destroyed the partial or total structures of affected bones, the 3-D tumor models appeared to be incomplete. It was not suitable for prosthesis design. In this scenario, the images of contralateral anatomical site were used to create a 3-D mirror model for prosthesis design. Under virtual condition, the tumor was simulated to be excised and the prosthesis was fixed at the defect site. The authors could rotate the 3-D model to observe and refine the prosthesis design until the most appropriate one was selected. In comparison to stainless steel (190 GPa) and cobalt-chrome (230 GPa), titanium (110 GPa) is considered a low modulus metal. However, its modulus is still six times greater than cortical bone (7–30 GPa). This mismatch in Young’s modulus creates a stress-shielding effect . To solve this problem, the porous structure was introduced into the titanium prosthesis design to reduce the modulus. Finally, the safe margin, cutting plane, implant position, and screw sites were preoperatively planned and marked on 3-D model basing on surgical approach and exposure.
Manufacturing the TAV prosthesis
From November 2011 to June 2012, three female patients with malignant tumors received operative treatments in our department. X-ray, CT, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), and single-photon emission computed tomography/CT (SPECT/CT) scan were performed on all patients to determine the tumor margin, tumor stage, and cutting plane. All patients underwent needle biopsy before surgery to obtain pathological diagnoses. The preoperative diagnoses were clavicle Ewing’s sarcoma (ES) in one patient, scapular ES in one, and pelvic chondrosarcoma (CS) in one. Adjuvant chemotherapy was administrated in patients with ES. The study was approved by the institutional review board of Xi-Jing Hospital, Fourth Military Medical University (FMMU). All patients provided their written informed consent, which was recorded and saved by the staff of the ethics committee of Xi-Jing hospital.
Follow-up and survival
Local recurrence, metastasis, functional results, and complications were followed up every 3 months for the first two years, then 6 months for the third year. The plain radiographs, chest CT scan, MRI, and bone scintigraphy scan were used for follow-up purposes. The functions were evaluated by MSTS93 functional score .
Demographic and clinical data
Pelvic CS (IIB)
28 (93 %)
22 (73 %)
27 (90 %)
PubMed search did not retrieve large studies on clinical application of customized prosthesis manufactured by RP technique. The potential advantage of RP technique lies within the possibility of manufacturing the complicated customized prostheses in greatly reduced time. Although the standard prosthesis is commercially available to meet the requirements in most surgical procedures, customized prosthesis is still needed in some cases. The indications for customized prosthesis are as follows: (1) patients outside the standard range with respect to implant size, implant morphology, or disease-specific special requirements; and (2) improved surgical outcome because of individual fitting and adequate match with individual anatomical needs .
The RP technique has been applied in reconstructing various anatomical structures especially in craniomaxillofacial surgery. In this scenario, a customized medical implant and surgical resection template is accurately designed using a CAD technique. The physical model of the individual implant, template, or skull replica can be produced through RP process. The CAD data of prosthesis are imported into RP machine to fabricate the physical object. The stereolithography apparatus prosthesis pattern is directly used in investment casting for production of TAV prosthesis. Singare et al.  reported two patients with large maxillary bone defects received customized prostheses implantation. The prosthesis perfectly fitted the defects during the operation and surgery time was greatly reduced. D’Urso et al.  reviewed the outcome of 30 patients who underwent cranioplasty surgeries. Data acquired from CT were used to manufacture exact plastic replicas of craniotomy defects and cranioplastic implants using RP technology. The 3-D mirror imaging was used to extrapolate existing anatomy to design implants. The customized prosthesis could reduce operating time and afford excellent cosmesis. Cho et al.  described the application of 3-D printing technology to fabricate a mirror-image single crown of a maxillary central incisor. A 73-year-old patient with a recently replaced metal ceramic crown had discomfort due to the non-anatomic lingual contour of the crown. With CAD software and RP technology, the shape of the contralateral central incisor was duplicated and reproduced to make a mirror-image for a new crown.
Customized prosthesis manufactured by RP technique was also applied in limb salvage surgeries. Wang et al. and Li et al. [24, 25] designed a customized hemi-knee joint trying to solve the problem of cartilage necrosis in hemi-joint allograft transplantation. Based on extracted 3-D contour images of articular cartilage, the artificial knee was designed with Surfacer 9.0 software. The 3-D contours of femoral condyle and subchondral bone were used to design the outer and inner surface of prosthesis, respectively. After the data were imported, the positive mold was fabricated by RP machine. It was used to manufacture prosthesis through mold-melted founding process. In combination with allograft, the prosthesis was used to treat the large defect after excision of distal femur sarcoma. It well matched the subchondral contour of the femoral condyle and provided an efficient way to prevent necrosis of allogenic cartilage in hemi-knee reconstruction. At 18 months postoperatively, the patient demonstrated satisfactory knee joint function. Dai et al.  reported their experience in customized hemi-pelvic prostheses implantation in ten patients who underwent internal hemi-pelvectomy for extensive pelvic tumors. The CT data were converted into stereolithographic file and processed by Magic RP software. The images of lesion and contralateral normal site were viewed and evaluated. Then, the data were exported to a RP machine and a pelvic model was made. After the simulated bone resection was done on the model, the hemi-pelvic prosthesis was designed and manufactured. The simulated installation and revision were performed on the model. The prosthesis was then implanted to reconstruct hip function. Except that four patients died of disease within 6 to 10 months postoperatively, the remaining six patients had good hip function after follow-up ranging from 21 to 48 months. However, the prostheses in these reports were still manufactured through mold-melted founding process. The RP technique was only used to fabricate positive mold. There was still no clinical report on manufacturing prosthesis directly through 3-D printing machine.
Although amputation is the most commonly used treatment in the last century for large tumors involving the clavicle, scapula, and pelvis, limb salvage has now become the consensus procedure for most cases. This is mostly attributed to improvements in preoperative imaging evaluation, more effective neoadjuvant chemotherapy, and advances in surgical technique. The development of customized titanium alloy prosthesis has augmented the limb salvage surgery in recent years.
Even though it is biologically compatible, titanium has difficulties in molding, casting, and milling. The shaping of titanium onto a model is limited by the artistic aptitude of technician and can be unreliable. CNC milling is also limited by difficulties encountered when trying to replicate complex anatomy or internal features due to collision between the milling tool and the object. With the development of RP technique, the accurate production of prosthesis with complicated morphology and internal features has become possible . Metal RP processes like EBM and selective laser sintering can directly manufacture patient-specific medical TAV implants and devices. In the current study, three kinds of prosthesis manufactured by EBM were implanted to repair the defects in unusual sites. Compared to traditional manufacturing process, EBM greatly simplifies the processing steps and considerably reduced fabricating time. It shows a promising tendency in manufacturing customized prosthesis. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) of the USA has recently approved the production of certain products fabricated using Arcam’s EBM process. Besides fabricating customized implants, several companies, including Adler Ortho (Italy), have used EBM to manufacture some special structures of standard prosthesis. For example, the lattice structure of acetabular cup is crucial for osteointegration in hip replacement. But the traditional manufacturing methods are complicated and time-consuming. Now, EBM has been used to fabricate such structures. This direct metal fabrication technique can eliminate several process steps associated with traditional methods . Also in artificial hip system, the stem is usually much stiffer than host bone and, over time, this can cause stress shielding, bone resorption, and implant loosening. Additive processes allow the structure of the stem to be optimized to match the stiffness, or flexibility, of the host bone, reducing stress shielding .
Both surgeons and patients have benefited from RP technique. Provision of a preoperatively customized prosthesis and 3-D model can allow the surgeons to assess implant fit preoperatively, evaluate fixation sites, obtain a valuable overview of the procedure, and reduce operation time. The patients are able to see the 3-D model and implant preoperatively, which improves their understanding of the procedure.
In this case series, reconstructions were performed in the clavicle, scapula, and ilium. Although good shoulder function was reported to be achieved without reconstruction after total claviculectomy, the authors indicated that restoration was still needed basing on the requirements of function and cosmesis. The clavicle can provide protection for the major vessels and nerves at the base of the neck. Likewise, it serves a cosmetic function by providing a graceful curve. It also works as a strut to hold the glenohumeral joint in the parasagittal plane and increase the range of motion. The patient showed good shoulder function (MSTS score 93 %) and satisfactory ROM (Flexion 90°, extension 35°, abduction 80°), which correlated with the results of other studies [11, 29]. Regarding to the total scapulectomy, it required not only joint resection but also wide excision of shoulder girdle muscles. Residual function is usually minimal and unsatisfactory. Although various reconstructions after total scapulectomy have been applied, such as prosthetic replacement, recycled bone grafts, or soft tissue reconstruction, the optimal reconstruction has not yet been determined because the amount of remaining muscle and rotator cuff following scapulectomy varies with each surgery. Therefore, preoperative evaluation of medical images to confirm safe margins of excision is mandatory. In the current case, the glenoid was affected by tumor. The shoulder girdle was reconstructed with the remaining soft tissue and scapular prosthesis, which restored glenohumeral articulation. In contrary to the commonly used reconstruction with constrained total scapula prosthesis, only the scapula was replaced with customized implant considering for sparing of enough muscles. Soft tissue reconstructions including humeral suspension, reattaching the rotator cuff, and suturing the biceps tendons onto the clavicle were performed. The patient obtained benefit from this reconstruction, and functions were acceptable in comparison with the results of another study . Although scapular allograft reconstruction was reported with satisfactory outcomes, resorption of allograft was observed and remained a distinct concern . Therefore, TAV scapular prosthesis was preferred in current study.
Our study also had several limitations. Firstly, it was limited by the short-term follow-up and lack of control for comparison purposes between different reconstruction methods. The authors can only provide the preliminary results to introduce this technique in the current study. Secondly, the 3-D-printed prosthesis is not widely used due to the following reasons: (1) the complicated approval process, (2) the high price, and (3) the low incidence of sarcoma in unusual anatomy site, where no commercial modular prosthesis can be used. It was difficult to obtain a large number of patients in one institution. The small sample size did not allow sufficient power to explore the advantages of RP techniques. Thirdly, the porous structure was introduced into the design of prosthesis in order to reduce the modulus. But the final modulus of implant was not tested in this study. In spite of these shortcomings, the current study still added further information on customized prosthesis manufactured by EBM.
EBM, a metal RP process, was used to directly manufacture customized TAV prostheses in this study. With the aid of CAOS, the accurate excision and precise reconstruction were achieved. These implants fitted the patient-specific anatomy well. The follow-up results proved the safety and effectiveness of prostheses. Although this single-center study is small in scale and the follow-up time is short, the results still demonstrate the advantages of this technology.
This work was supported by grants from National Science Foundation of China (No.51271199) and project on Transformation of Scientific Achievements of Shaanxi Province, China (No.2012KTCG01-14).
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.
- Lietman SA, Joyce MJ. Bone sarcomas: overview of management, with a focus on surgical treatment considerations. Cleve Clin J Med. 2010;77 Suppl 1:S8–12.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Schuh R, Panotopoulos J, Puchner SE, Willegger M, Hobusch GM, Windhager R, et al. Vascularised or non-vascularised autologous fibular grafting for the reconstruction of a diaphyseal bone defect after resection of a musculoskeletal tumour. Bone Joint J. 2014;96-B(9):1258–63.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Fan H, Guo Z, Wang Z, Li J, Li X. Surgical technique: unicondylar osteoallograft prosthesis composite in tumor limb salvage surgery. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2012;470:3577–86.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Pala E, Henderson ER, Calabrò T, Angelini A, Abati CN, Trovarelli G, et al. Survival of current production tumor endoprostheses: complications, functional results, and a comparative statistical analysis. J Surg Oncol. 2013;108:403–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ji T, Guo W, Yang RL, Tang XD, Wang YF. Modular hemipelvic endoprosthesis reconstruction—experience in 100 patients with mid-term follow-up results. Eur J Surg Oncol. 2013;39:53–60.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Guo W, Li D, Tang X, Yang Y, Ji T. Reconstruction with modular hemipelvic prostheses for periacetabular tumor. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2007;461:180–8.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Witte D, Bernd L, Bruns J, Gosheger G, Hardes J, Hartwig E, et al. Limb-salvage reconstruction with MUTARS hemipelvic endoprosthesis: a prospective multicenter study. Eur J Surg Oncol. 2009;35:1318–25.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Jaiswal PK, Aston WJ, Grimer RJ, Abudu A, Carter S, Blunn G, et al. Peri-acetabular resection and endoprosthetic reconstruction for tumours of the acetabulum. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2008;90:1222–7.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Chandrasekar CR, Grimer RJ, Carter SR, Tillman RM, Abudu A, Buckley L. Modular endoprosthetic replacement for tumours of the proximal femur. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2009;91:108–12.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kabukcuoglu Y, Grimer RJ, Tillman RM, Carter SR. Endoprosthetic replacementfor primary malignant tumors of the proximal femur. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1999;358:8–14.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Guo Z, Wang Z, Wang Z, Zhang Y. Allograft of clavicle for reconstruction of bone defect after tumor resection. Zhongguo Xiu Fu Chong Jian Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2008;22:102–5.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Mnaymneh WA, Temple HT, Malinin TI. Allograft reconstruction after resection of malignant tumors of the scapula. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2002;405:223–9.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Puchner SE, Panotopoulos J, Puchner R, Schuh R, Windhager R, Funovics PT. Primary malignant tumours of the scapula—a review of 29 cases. Int Orthop. 2014;38:2155–62.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Shinjo K. Reconstruction of a segmental clavicular defect with a Marlex mesh-enveloped composite graft consisting of a hydroxyapatite prosthesis and autogenous bone: a case report. Jpn J Clin Oncol. 1992;22:221–4.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Rengier F, Mehndiratta A, von Tengg-Kobligk H, Zechmann CM, Unterhinninghofen R, Kauczor HU, et al. 3D printing based on imaging data: review of medical applications. Int J Comput Assist Radiol Surg. 2010;5:335–41.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ponader S, von Wilmowsky C, Widenmayer M, Lutz R, Heinl P, Körner C, et al. In vivo performance of selective electron beam-melted Ti-6Al-4V structures. J Biomed Mater Res A. 2010;92:56–62.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Li J, Li P, Lu H, Shen L, Tian W, Long J, et al. Digital design and individually fabricated titanium implants for the reconstruction of traumatic zygomatico-orbital defects. J Craniofac Surg. 2013;24:363–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Dewidar M, Mohamed HF, Lim JK. A new approach for manufacturing a high porosity Ti-6Al-4V scaffolds for biomedical applications. J Mater Sci Technol. 2008;24:931–5.Google Scholar
- Enneking WF, Dunham W, Gebhardt MC. A system for the functional evaluation of reconstructive procedures after surgical treatment of tumors of the musculoskeletal system. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1993;286:241–6.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Malawer MM. Tumors of the shoulder girdle. Technique of resection and description of a surgical classification. Orthop Clin North Am. 1991;22:7–35.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Singare S, Liu Y, Li D, Lu B, Wang J, He S. Individually prefabricated prosthesis for maxilla reconstuction. J Prosthodont. 2008;17:135–40.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- D'Urso PS, Earwaker WJ, Barker TM, Redmond MJ, Thompson RG, Effeney DJ, et al. Custom cranioplasty using stereolithography and acrylic. Br J Plast Surg. 2000;53:200–4.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Cho SH, Chang WG. Mirror-image anterior crown fabrication with computer-aided design and rapid prototyping technology: a clinical report. J Prosthet Dent. 2013;109:75–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Wang Z, Teng Y, Li D. Fabrication of custom-made artificial semi-knee joint based on rapid prototyping technique: computer-assisted design and manufacturing. Zhongguo Xiu Fu Chong Jian Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2014;18:347–51.Google Scholar
- Li Z, Xu SF, Li DC, Sun Z, Zhang T, Lu JX, et al. Composite artificial semi-knee joint system. Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci. 2014;18:1229–40.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Dai KR, Yan MN, Zhu ZA, Sun YH. Computer-aided custom-made hemipelvic prosthesis used in extensive pelvic lesions. J Arthroplasty. 2007;22:981–6.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Horn TJ, Harrysson OL. Overview of current additive manufacturing technologies and selected applications. Sci Prog. 2012;95(Pt 3):255–82.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Harrysson O, Cansizoglu O, Marcellin-Little DJ, Cormier DR, West II HA. Direct metal fabrication of titanium implants with tailored materials and mechanical properties using electron beam melting technology. Mat Sci Eng C. 2008;28:366–73.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Rodriguez Martin J, Pretell Mazzini J, Viña Fernandez R, Marti Ciruelos R. Curto de la Mano A. Ewing sarcoma of clavicle in children: report of 5 cases. J Pediatr Hematol Oncol. 2009;31:820–4.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Tang X, Guo W, Yang R, Ji T, Sun X. Reconstruction with constrained prosthesis after total scapulectomy. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2011;20:1163–9.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar