- Open Access
Nulliparity enhances the risk of second primary malignancy of the breast in a cohort of women treated for thyroid cancer
© Consorti et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2011
- Received: 2 March 2011
- Accepted: 12 August 2011
- Published: 12 August 2011
Many studies have reported an increased risk of developing a second primary malignancy (SPM) of the breast in women treated for thyroid cancer. In this study, we investigated several potential risk factors for this association. The aim of this retrospective cohort study was to identify a subgroup of women surgically treated for papillary thyroid cancer that may benefit from more careful breast cancer screening.
A total of 101 women surgically treated for papillary thyroid cancer from 1996 to 2009 with subsequent follow-up were interviewed by phone regarding personal risk factors and lifestyle habits. Only 75 questionnaires could be evaluated due to a 25.7% rate of patients not retrieved or refusing the interview. Data analysis was performed using a multivariate logistic model.
The standardised incidence ratio (SIR) for breast cancer was 3.58 (95% IC 1.14 - 8.37). Our data suggest a protective effect of multiparity on the development of a SPM of the breast (O.R. 0.15; 95% IC 0.25 - 0.86). Significant associations were not found with other known risk factors including Body Mass Index (BMI), age at first tumour, concurrent metabolic diseases, smoking, physical activity and familiarity.
This study confirms that a higher incidence of SPM of the breast is observed in women treated for papillary thyroid cancer. Additionally, this risk is increased by nulliparity, thus a strict breast screening program for nulliparous women treated for thyroid cancer may be advisable.
- thyroid cancer
- breast cancer
- second primary malignancy
- risk factor
Papillary thyroid cancer is the most commonly observed endocrine neoplasm. Its overall age standardised rate in Italy is 9.1 cases/100.000 persons/year, even if its incidence is higher in women (14.3). The mortality rate is much lower, accounting 0.4 death/100.000 . Because thyroid cancer survivors may live for several decades following diagnosis, they may develop a second primary malignancy (SPM). In a meta-analysis conducted by Subramanian et al., 1409 publications were reviewed, and they found that breast carcinoma is the most frequent SPM in women treated for thyroid carcinoma . Several large studies analysed the incidence of SPM of the breast using cancer registries [3–5], but these studies did not focus on possible risk co-factors, such as the lifestyle or family and past medical history of the women. The present study examined common risk factors for breast carcinoma in a cohort of women surgically treated for papillary thyroid carcinoma. Based on these factors, our goal was to identify a subgroup of women with an increased risk of developing a SPM of the breast that may benefit from more careful mammary screening.
Women with a histological diagnosis of papillary thyroid cancer and available follow-up data were selected from a database of patients surgically treated from 1996 to 2009 for thyroid disease at one of the Departments of Surgery of Policlinico Umberto I in Rome. A total of 101 women with papillary thyroid cancer were present in the database and were all included in this retrospective cohort study. A questionnaire was designed to guide a phone interview to investigate patients' personal risk factors and lifestyle habits (additional file 1). All patients were called and interviewed by the same individual. Each interview lasted approximately ten minutes. In total, 75 interviews were conducted. Of the selected 101 women, 26 of these patients (25.7%) were unavailable for interviews (2 did not survive, 22 could not be reached via phone and 2 refused the interview).
Data analysis was performed using univariate and multivariate logistic models. In addition, the ratio between expected and observed incidence of breast cancer during the follow-up period was calculated (SIR: standardised incidence ratio = expected/observed). Confidence intervals were calculated from a poissonian distribution for standardised rates, according to .
Of the 75 patients who answered the questionnaire, the mean age at the diagnosis of papillary cancer was 57.35 ± 12.75 years, with a mean follow-up period at the moment of the interview of 74.52 ± 12.75 months (6.21 ± 1.06 years). In the follow up period after the diagnosis of papillary thyroid cancer, 7 SPMs of the breast were observed. All these 7 patients had been already operated at the moment of the interview and their diagnosis of breast cancer had been histologically confirmed. The mean time interval between the diagnosis of thyroid cancer and the subsequent diagnosis of breast cancer was 5.80 ± 3.24 years. Two cases of detected breast cancer occurred within 2 years from the papillary carcinoma diagnosis and they were not considered in the SIR calculation. According to many other similar studies[3, 4], these cases were considered to occur concurrently to thyroid cancer.
Logistic regression analysis of measured factors
Odds ratio (95% CI)
Odds ratio (95% CI)
Age at first tumor
1.06 (0.98 - 1.14)
1.07 (0.97 - 1.18)
Concurrent metabolic diseases
0.82 (0.15 - 4.40)
0.08 (0.00 - 1.56)
Family history of breast cancer
1.06* (0.10 - 0.88)
Distribution of risks factors, life-style habits and past medical history in the sample
BMI (Body Mass Index) mean ± SD
26.83 ± 4.74
Education level n (%)
Parity n (%)
Smoke n (%)
Alcohol use n (%)
Physical activity n (%)
Menopause n (%)
Menarche mean age ± SD
12.38 ± 1.33
Concurrent metabolic diseases n (%)
Diabetes type 2
Diabetes type 2 and dyslipidemia
Diabetes type 2 and hypertension
Dyslipidemia and hypertension
Family history of thyroid cancer n (%)
Family history of breast cancer n (%)
SPM (Second Primary Malignancy) n (%)
Benign breast disease n (%)
Twenty-four patients (32%) did not follow a regular breast screening program. Because we only conducted a phone interview and not a clinical exam of the women, the actual number of SPMs of the breast could have been underestimated.
Additionally, 72 of the 75 patients underwent radioactive iodine therapy.
The incidence of thyroid cancer has almost doubled in Italy between the periods 1991-1995 and 2001-2005. This trend is almost exclusively due to an increase in papillary thyroid cancer (PTC) . The mortality rate for patients diagnosed with thyroid cancer, however, has declined , and the 15 year survival rate is approximately 80% . Due to this prolonged survival time, development of a SPM is becoming an actual possibility for thyroid cancer survivors. For example, it is known that women treated for thyroid cancer have an increased incidence of subsequent breast cancer compared to the general population , and our research confirms this finding. We identified 7 patients with breast cancer among the 75 women previously treated for papillary thyroid cancer. Five of the cases were documented more than two years from the initial diagnosis of PTC. The mean follow-up period was 6.21 years, resulting in a SIR of 3.58 (95% IC 1.14-8.37).
In a meta-analysis conducted by Subramanian et al., a pooled SIR of 1.25 (95% CI 1.17-1.32) was calculated for breast SPMs from a group of 83292 patients. This SIR was lower than our calculated SIR. It is important to note that the sample size used in our study was smaller and our confidence interval was larger than those calculated in the meta-analysis, but our study includes the SIR value of the meta-analysis (i.e., 1.25). Furthermore, we found that 24 of the 75 women (32%) questioned did not follow a regular breast screening program; therefore, the number of breast SPMs detected could have been an underestimate. Additionally, Adjadj et al. observed an increased risk of breast cancer among thyroid cancer patients and was unable to detect a significant correlation with treatment (radiotherapy or radioactive iodine therapy) of the initial cancer. Because the mammary gland has the same sodium-iodine symport as the thyroid gland, radioactive iodine could be implicated in breast carcinogenesis. Additionally, radiotherapy treatment could induce women of childbearing age to delay pregnancy, and parity is a known protective factor for breast cancer, especially in younger women .
Although Canchola et al. detected a higher incidence only of in situ SPM breast cancer, we observed an increased risk of invasive breast cancer. Chen et al. (2001)  and Brown et al. (2008)  observed a higher incidence of SPM of the breast in 25-49-year-old women previously treated for thyroid cancer than in older women. Despite these results, we were unable to detect a significant correlation between the incidence of breast cancer and young age. It is important to note that the mean age at first tumour diagnosis in our sample population was 57.35 ± 12.75 years. This mean age was higher than that observed in the series from Chen et al. and Brown et al., reflecting the general trend for the mean age at tumour onset in Italian populations .
According to Rubino et al. and Sawka et al.[13, 14], thyroid cancer patients treated with radioactive iodine have an increased risk of developing several SPMs, including leukemia or bone cancer, but not breast cancer. Because 72 of the 75 patients (96%) were treated with radioactive iodine, we were unable to assess the correlation between breast SPM risk and radioactive iodine treatment in our study.
Previously, the majority of studies on the incidence of SPM following thyroid cancer were based on cancer registries. Consequently, they could not take detailed personal data into account, and important information such as life style and personal risk factors of patients were not analysed. Using phone interviews, we investigated several potential risk factors involved in the association between thyroid and subsequent breast cancers. The aim of this retrospective cohort study was to identify a subgroup of women surgically treated for papillary thyroid cancer that may necessitate a more careful mammary screening.
Based on our analysis, we observed a significant protective effect of multiparity for SPM of the breast. Obesity has been associated with increased incidence of thyroid cancer . In our study, the majority of patients were overweight with a mean BMI of 26.83 ± 4.74 Kg/m2. We were unable to detect a significant association between weight and risk using both univariate and multivariate analyses. Despite the fact that women with a first-degree relative suffering from breast cancer have a higher risk of developing primary breast cancer , a significant association was not detected with family history.
Study limitations and perspectives for the future
This retrospective cohort study only included 101 patients, thus a larger patient population is needed to confirm our findings. Furthermore, we were unable to detect a significant association between young age and SPM, but the mean age for our sample population was higher than those reported in other studies [3, 4, 10].
Age of the first live birth as well as the number of children could be relevant information. Nevertheless, in this study we tried to keep the interview as short and simple as possible and to consider only dichotomous variables for calculation. Starting now from the consideration that childbearing is a risk factor, more addressed and large studies are needed to define in details extent and meaning of this finding. An additional limitation to the study was the loss of 25.7% of the initial 101 patients due to interview unavailability. It is possible that our results may have been different if the other 22 interviews had been collected, even if there is not a reason to presume a specific direction for this potential bias. In fact, personal characteristics of this sub-group, as recorded in the database, were similar to the rest of the sample.
The pathophysiologic relationship between thyroid and breast cancer is not clearly understood. Potential hypotheses for the link between these tissues include a genetic predisposition, dysregulation of the immune system or a hormonal cause. Additionally, the observed increased incidence of breast SPM could be artificial because women previously treated for cancer may be more cautious with their health.
Hall et al. demonstrated in vitro that thyroid hormones (T3) may function to mimic or enhance the effect of oestrogens on breast cancer cell proliferation. Based on this information, it is clear that the effect of high l-thyroxine doses on breast tissue during suppressive hormonal therapy following thyroidectomy in thyroid cancer patients should to be investigated. According to the experimental hypothesis that high l-thyroxine doses could enhance the risk of breast cancer, hormone replacement therapy for postmenopausal women should also be investigated as a possible risk factor. This information was too detailed to be collected by a phone interview in this study, because of the large number of commercially available products.
This study confirms that there is an increased incidence of breast SPM in women treated for papillary thyroid cancer. With the exception of nulliparity, we were unable to detect significant associations between the incidence of SPM and several known risk factors. From a methodological perspective, the questionnaire design was appropriate. It allowed for a detailed phone interview that only required 10 minutes of time from each patient. Based on our findings, a strict breast screening program for nulliparous women treated for thyroid cancer may be advisable. Although we were able to detect a significant association, larger studies are necessary to confirm our findings and investigate other potential risk factors (e.g., suppressive hormonal therapy).
- GLOBOCAN 2008 Cancer Incidence and Mortality Worldwide in 2008. http://globocan.iarc.fr/
- Subramanian S, Goldstein DP, Parlea L, Thabane L, Ezzat S, Ibrahim-Zada I, Straus S, Brierley JD, Tsang RW, Gafni A, Rotstein L, Sawka AM: Second Primary Malignancy Risk in Thyroid Cancer Survivors: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. THYROID. 2007, 17: 1277-1289. 10.1089/thy.2007.0171.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Chen AY, Levy L, Goepfert H, Brown BW, Spitz MR, Vassilopoulou-Sellin R: The Development of Breast Carcinoma in Women with Thyroid Carcinoma. CANCER. 2001, 92: 225-231. 10.1002/1097-0142(20010715)92:2<225::AID-CNCR1313>3.0.CO;2-B.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Adjadj E, Rubino C, Shamsaldim A, G Lê M, Schlumberger M, de Vathaire F: The Risk of Multiple Primary Breast and Thyroid Carcinomas. CANCER. 2003, 6: 1309-1317.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Canchola AJ, Horn-Ross PL, Purdie DM: Risk of Second Primary Malignancies in Women with Papillary Thyroid Cancer. Am J Epidemiol. 2006, 163: 521-527. 10.1093/aje/kwj072.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Morris JA, Gardner MJ: Calculating confidence intervals for relative risks (odds ratios) and standardised ratios and rates. Br Med J (Clin Res Ed). 1988, 296 (6632): 1313-1316. 10.1136/bmj.296.6632.1313.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Piscitelli P, Santoriello A, Buonaguro FM, Di Maio M, Iolascon G, Gimigliano F, Marinelli A, Distante A, Serravezza G, Sordi E, Cagossi K, Artioli F, Santangelo M, Fucito A, Gimigliano R, Brandi ML, Crespi M, Giordano A: Incidence Of Breast Cancer In Italy: Mastectomies And Quadrantectomies Performed Between 2000 and 2005. J Exp & Clin Cancer Res. 2009, 28: 86-10.1186/1756-9966-28-86.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Dal Maso L, Lise M, Zambon P, Falcini F, Crocetti E, Serraino D, Cirilli C, Zanetti R, Vercelli M, Ferretti S, Stracci F, De Lisi V, Busco S, Tagliabue G, Budroni M, Tumino R, Giacomin A & Franceschi S for AIRTUM Working Group: Incidence Of Thyroid Cancer In Italy, 1991-2005: Time Trends And Age-Period-Cohort Effects. Ann Oncol. 2010,Google Scholar
- La Vecchia C, Bosetti C, Bertuccio P, Negri E, Boyle P, Levi F: Cancer Mortality In Europe, 2000-2004, And An Overview Of Trends Since 1975. Ann Oncol. 2010, 21 (6): 1323-1360. 10.1093/annonc/mdp530.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- AIRT Rapporto tumori 2006, e&p. 2006, 2: 80-81. accessed on 09/12/2010, http://www.registri-tumori.it/incidenza1998-2002/rapporto/Schede%20specifiche%20per%20tumore/Tumore%20della%20tiroide.pdf
- Brown AP, Chen J, Hitchcock YJ, Szabo A, Shrieve DC, Tward JD: The Risk of Second Primary Malignancies up to Three Decades after the Treatment of Differentiated Thyroid Cancer. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2008, 93 (2): 504-515. 10.1210/jc.2007-1154.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Lester SC, Cotran RS: Mammary Gland. Robbins Pathologic Basis Of Disease. Edited by: Cotran, Kumar, Collins. 1999, Philadelphia: Saunders, 1282-1284. 6Google Scholar
- Rubino C, de Vathaire F, Dottorini ME, Hall P, Schvartz C, Couette JE, Dondon MG, Abbas MT, Langlois C, Schlumberger M: Second Primary Malignancies In Thyroid Cancer Patients. Br J of Cancer. 2003, 89: 1638-1644. 10.1038/sj.bjc.6601319.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sawka AM, Thabane L, Parlea L, Ibrahim-Zada I, Tsang RW, Brierley JD, Straus S, Ezzat S, Goldstein DP: Second Primary Malignancy Risk After Radioactive Iodine Treatment for Thyroid Cancer: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. THYROID. 2009, 19: 451-456. 10.1089/thy.2008.0392.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Paes JE, Hua K, Nagy R, Kloos RT, Jarjoura D, and Ringel MD: The Relationship Between Body Mass Index And Thyroid Cancer Pathology Features And Outcomes: A Clinicopathological Cohort Study. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2010, 95 (9): 4244-4250. 10.1210/jc.2010-0440.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hall LC, Salazar EP, Kanea SR, Liu N: Effects Of Thyroid Hormones On Human Breast Cancer Cell Proliferation. J Steroid Biochem & Molec Biol. 2008, 109: 57-66. 10.1016/j.jsbmb.2007.12.008.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.