Table 4 Systematic review of long-term survival outcomes
From: Systematic review and meta-analysis of laparoscopic and open gastrectomy for advanced gastric cancer
Author | Group | Follow-up (months) | Recurrence | DFS rate | OS rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Huscher | LG | 60 (2–88) | 11 | 5-y: 57.3 | 5-y: 58.9 |
OG | 55 (7–90) | 10 | 5-y: 54.8 | 5-y: 55.7 | |
Hur | LG | 29 (6–47) | 8 | 3-y: 71.4 | 3-y: 88.2 |
OG | 6 | 3-y: 53.4 | 3-y: 77.2 | ||
Du XH | LG | 25.2 (4–58) | 22 | NR | 3-y: 81.2 |
OG | 31 | NR | 3-y: 74.7 | ||
Hwang | LG | 23 (9–40) | 6 | NR | NR |
OG | 23.5 (8–41) | 17 | NR | NR | |
Du J | LAG | 25 (2–44) | 19 | NR | NR |
OG | 23 | NR | NR | ||
Cai | LG | 22.1 (4–36) | NR | NR | 3-y: 67.1 |
OG | NR | NR | 3-y: 53.8 | ||
Scatizzi | LG | 18 (2–37) | NR | NR | 3-y: 70.9 |
OG | 18 (7–42) | NR | NR | 3-y: 56.8 | |
Shuang | LG | 36.5 (23–50) | NR | NR | NR |
OG | 38.5 (27–50) | NR | NR | NR | |
Zhao | LG | 37 (6–72) | 147 | 5-y: 47 | 1-y: 87.2, 3-y: 57.2, 5-y: 50.3 |
OG | 141 | 5-y: 46.8 | 1-y: 87.1, 3-y: 54.1, 5-y: 49.2 | ||
Chen | LG | 19 (1–48) | NR | NR | 1-y: 91.5 |
OG | NR | NR | 1-y: 89.8 | ||
Chun | LG | 53.2 (1–82.2) | 4 | NR | 5-y: 91.3 |
OG | 60.4 (7–91.7) | 7 | NR | 5-y: 88.6 | |
Kim | LG | 53.7 (8.3−138.1) | 13 | 5-y: 84.6 | 5-y: 85.9 |
OG | 58.1 (0.3−106.2) | 15 | 5-y: 81.1 | 5-y: 83.1 | |
Moisan | LG | 28 | 5 | 3-y: 79.4 | 3-y: 82.3 |
OG | 40 | 4 | 3-y: 83.4 | 3-y: 86.9 | |
Siani | LG | 32.6 | NR | 5-y: 54.2 | 5-y: 55.7 |
OG | 31.9 | NR | 5-y: 52.1 | 5-y: 52.9 | |
Shinohara | LG | 48.8 (25–58.5)a | 53 | 5-y: 65.8b | 5-y: 68.1b |
OG | 34 | 5-y: 62.0b | 5-y: 63.7b |