Sleeve lobectomy versus pneumonectomy for non-small cell lung cancer: a meta-analysis

Table 1 Study characteristics included in the meta-analysis

Authors	Year	Number		Mean age		Male/female		Stage I		Stage II		≥ Stage III
Authors	Year	SL	PN	SL	PN	SL	PN	SL	PN	SL	PN	SL	PN
Gaissert et al.	1996	72	56	63.4	60.8	56/16	42/14	29	9	31	25	12	22
Yoshino et al.^a	1997	29	29	60.6	58.2	26/3	23/6	9	9	12	12	8	8
Suen et al.^b	1999	58	142	63.7	66.5	41/17	81/61	18	37	28	46	12	59
Okada et al.	2000	60	60	60.9	60.6	52/8	53/7	/	/	/	/	/	/
Ghiribelli et al.	2002	38	127	65	62.4	36/2	102/25	16	29	10	43	12	55
Martin et al.	2002	38	81	65	63	27/11	63/18	10	10	16	32	12	39
Deslauriers et al.	2004	184	1,046	60	60.7	152/32	827/219	82	164	72	361	30	521
Bagan et al.	2005	66	151	60.7	58.16	58/8	138/13	40	35	14	35	12	81
Kim et al.	2005	49	49	58.7	58.1	44/5	46/3	14	24	20	13	15	12
Lausberg et al.	2005	171	63	61.5	60.9	136/35	56/7	33	7	80	32	58	24
Ludwig et al.	2005	116	194	62	59	/	/	31	32	41	52	44	110
Takeda et al.	2006	62	110	61.1	59.3	46/16	92/18	26	24	19	14	17	72
Balduyck et al.	2008	10	20	65.3	63.3	/	/	2	3	1	9	7	8
Melloul et al.	2008	69	78	/	/	/	/	15	28	30	21	24	29
Parissis et al.	2009	79	129	60.44	62.5	54/25	91/38	/	/	/	/	/	/
Hanagiri et al.^c	2010	24	72	65.1	64.7	18/6	61/11	5	5	8	13	11	54
Park et al.	2010	105	105	61.25	62.24	99/6	98/7	44	43	32	36	29	26
Bolukbas et al.	2011	31	29	73.6	74.2	25/6	25/4	5	2	17	10	9	17
Gomez-Caro et al.	2011	55	21	63.5	62.4	51/4	18/3	33	7	20	13	2	1
Total		1,316	2,562	62.89	62.06	921/200	1,816/454	412	468	451	767	314	1,138

^aContaining two cases of small-cell carcinoma in the sleeve lobectomy (SL) group and one in the pneumonectomy (PN) group; ^bcontaining two cases of resection of the tracheal carina in SL; ^ccontaining two cases of right upper sleeve lobectomy with carinoplasty in SL.

ISSN: 1477-7819