Skip to main content

Table 1 Basic information and remarks of the included papers

From: Segmental artery clamping versus main renal artery clamping in nephron-sparing surgery: updated meta-analysis

Study Year Type of study Language SAC MAC Operation methods Observed indicators Length of follow up NOS marks Overall conclusion in SAC compared with MAC
Daniele Mattevi 2018 Case-control English 42 15 RPN 1Mos 8 Equivalent
Tawatchai Taweemonkongsap 2018 Case-control English 38 27 RPN 18.2Mos 8 Equivalent , less number of patients with prolonged WIT
Gang Xu 2018 Case-control Chinese 25 31 LPN 3Mos 8 Equivalent , superior postoperative renal function
Pengtao Wei 2018 Case-control Chinese 29 36 LPN 3Mos 7 Equivalent , more, superior postoperative renal function
Yongjian Zhang 2018 Case-control Chinese 28 22 LPN 3days 7 More , equivalent , superior postoperative renal function
DeZhu Qi 2017 Case-control Chinese 31 32 LPN 12Mos 8 Equivalent , more, superior postoperative renal function
Qian Cai 2017 Randomized controlled trial Chinese 15 19 LPN 6Mos 8 Equivalent , more , postoperative renal function
Paulucci 2016 Propensity-score analysis English 66 132 RPN 24Mos 7 Equivalent
Pu Li 2016   English 314 152 LPN 70Mos 8 Equivalent , postoperative renal function
Furukawa 2016 Case-control English 19 20 RPN 1Mo 7 Equivalent , postoperative renal function
Komninos 2015 Case-control English 25 114 RPN 47Mos 8 Equivalent , superior postoperative renal function
Shin 2015 Case-control English 20 97 RPN 3Mos 7 Equivalent , postoperative renal function
Akca 2015 Case-control English 111 468 RPN 6Mos 7 Less , equivalent
Wu Wei 2015 Case-control Chinese 39 43 LPN 42Mos 6 Equivalent, postoperative renal function.
JianZhou Liu 2015 Case-control Chinese 29 27 LPN 36Mos 6 Equivalent , more, superior postoperative renal function
Peng Li 2015 Case-control Chinese 10 13 LPN 3Mos 8 More , equivalent, superior postoperative renal function
Yuan Ruan 2016 Case-control Chinese 45 45 LPN 22.5Mos 7 Equivalent in , less, superior postoperative renal function
Hao Yang 2015 Case-control Chinese 35 45 LPN 24Mos 6 Less , superior postoperative renal function
JianFeng Zhao 2015 Case-control Chinese 21 21 LPN Not mentioned 6 More , equivalent , superior early renal function
LiYong Xing 2014 Case-control Chinese 27 28 LPN Not mentioned 6 Equivalent
Harke 2014 Case-control English 15 15 RPN 8days 7 Equivalent , superior postoperative renal function
McClintock 2014 Case-control English 42 42 RPN 3Mos 8 Equivalent , superior postoperative renal function
Yue Gao 2014 Case-control Chinese 21 38 LPN 12Mos 6 More,equivalent , superior postoperative renal function
SiMei Zhu 2014 Case-control Chinese 13 44 LPN 6Mos 7 Equivalent , more, superior postoperative renal function
Desai 2014 Case-control English 58 63 RPN 6Mos 7 Longer, more, equivalent in , superior renal function
Sheng Li 2014 Case-control Chinese 18 38 LPN 4Mos 6 Equivalent , superior postoperative renal function
Borofsky 2013 Case-control English 27 27 RPN 1Mos 8 Equivalent , superior postoperative renal function
Martin 2012 Case-control English 13 32 RPN 3Mos 7 Equivalent
JianGang Gao 2012 Case-control Chinese 42 37 LPN 48Mos 6 More , less, eqiuvalent , superior postoperative renal function
Ng 2012 Case-control English 22 22 RPN 2Mos 8 Equivalent.
Pengfei Shao 2011 Case-control English 31 37 LPN 33Mos 8 Equivalent , superior early postoperative affected renal function
Nohara 2008 Case-control English 18 27 Not mentioned 8Mos 6 Equivalent , superior postoperative renal function
  1. Note: OT, WIT, PSM, blood transfusion rate, EBL, postoperative complications (Hemorrhage, hematuria, urine leak) LOS, Clavien classification (≥ 3)