Skip to main content

Table 6 Surgical outcomes of LG and OG

From: Laparoscopic versus open approach in gastrectomy for advanced gastric cancer: a systematic review

Reference

Blood loss (ml)

Operating time (min)

Harvested lymph node

LAG

OG

LAG

OG

LAG

OG

2010–2015

 Huang et al. [14]

131.91a

342.3

266.05a

223.78

25.81

27.47

 Cai et al. [15]

293.67

344.47

270.51

187.66

22.98

22.87

 Scatizzi et al. [16]

NA

NA

240a

180

31

37

 Zhao et al. [18]

128a

301

211

204

33.2

32.8

 Chen et al. [19]

82.7a

201.7

207.2

213

30.6

30.3

 Chun et al. [20]

NA

NA

207.7a

159.9

39.1

39.3

 Hamabe et al. [21]

158.3a

356.3

283.1a

225.9

63.7a

44

 Kim et al. [22]

NA

NA

228.3a

183.6

38.3

41.8

 Bo et al. [24]

196.9a

358.2

292.8a

242.1

35.2

37.4

 Gordon et al. [25]

107a

495

291a

235

35.92

36.59

 Lin et al. [26]

78.4a

200.4

212.7

226.4

30.2

28

 Shinohara et al. [27]

154.3a

388.7

369.7a

263.6

45.3

43.8

 Qiu et al. [29]

120a

227.3

259.5a

236.09

30.2

28.1

 Cui et al. [30]

99a

125

258a

194

29.3

30.1

 Wu et al. [31]

169.46a

193. 86

228.43a

207.59

19.84a

18.04

2016–2019

 Hao et al. [33]

154.5a

311.2

257.8a

231

30.4

28.1

 Hu et al. [34]

105.5a

117.3

217.3a

186

36.1

36.9

 Li1 et al. [35]

131.9

129.5

297.4a

198.1

33.7

33.1

 Li2 et al. [35]

94

97.9

214.2a

200.3

24.7

24.6

 Lu et al. [37]

250a

330

240a

190

18

19

 Xu1 et al. [39]

322

274

326a

203

24

25.6

 Zhang et al. [40]

143a

223

189

201

37

35

 Inokuchi et al. [41]

115a

420

316a

242

39

38

 Park et al. [43]

NA

NA

257.4a

183

37

39.7

 Shi et al. [44]

129a

215.8

238.1a

207.3

31.59

32.18

 Xu2 et al. [49]

273.7a

233.6

283.8a

191.5

21.6

22.4

 Chan et al. [45]

150a

275

321a

365

39.5

37.5

 Lee et al. [47]

138.3a

222

225.7a

162.3

46.6

46.9

 Wang et al. [48]

91.4a

117.5

242.5a

209.9

29.5

31.4

  1. LG laparoscopy gastrectomy, OG open gastrectomy
  2. aP < 0.05