Skip to main content

Table 1 Summary of the 63 included studies

From: Associations between BRAFV600E and prognostic factors and poor outcomes in papillary thyroid carcinoma: a meta-analysis

Study

Ethnic A: Asia C: Caucasia

PTC number positive/negative

BRAFV600E mutation rate, %

O'Neill [26]

A

85/22

79.4

Daliri [65]

A

28/41

40.6

Han [51]

A

353/146

70.7

HE [59]

A

119/68

63.6

Namba [28]

A

26/14

65.0

Ahn [27]

A

38/88

30.2

Hong1 [61]

A

120/73

62.2

Hong2 [61]

A

1792/639

73.7

Liu [12]

A

213/126

62.8

Jung [36]

A

162/48

77.1

Kim [41]

A

64/15

81.0

Kim [7, 43]

A

34/69

33.0

Kim [7]

A

149/54

73.4

Kim [66]

A

265/57

82.3

LEE [16]

A

58/42

42.0

Lee [9]

A

24/40

37.5

Lim [54]

A

2219/728

75.3

Liu [40]

A

47/54

46.5

Liu [12]

A

80/52

60.6

Rivera [42]

A

43/18

70.5

Khan [56]

A

15/45

25

Shao [58]

A

133/67

66.5

Wang [57]

A

80/35

69.6

Lee [16]

A

241/390

38.4

Puxeddu [22]

A

281/485

36.4

Yim [50]

A

123/41

75

Jo [44]

A

102/59

63.4

Zeng [62]

A

465/154

75.1

Henke [67]

A and C

340/168

66.9

Czarniecka [64]

C

38/50

43.2

Abrosimov [34]

C

23/17

57.5

Alzahrani [47]

C

96/185

34.2

Guerra [48]

C

90/78

53.6

Frasca [25]

C

60/41

59.4

Ahn [27]

C

217/286

45.4

Durante [20]

C

56/37

60.2

Nikiforova [21]

C

24/36

40.0

Frasca [25]

C

125/198

38.7

Fugazzola [8]

C

99/161

38.1

Basolo [32]

C

472/575

45.1

Basolo [32]

C

229/349

39.6

Oler [49]

C

48/25

65.8

Howell [14]

C

86/133

39.3

Nakayama [29]

C

173/124

58.2

Fernandez [30]

C

153/143

51.7

Fugazzola [6]

C

18/29

38.3

Lee [69]

C

44/19

70

Li [55]

C

297/91

76.5

Yip [39]

C

99/100

49.7

Jung [36]

C

19/24

44.2

Durante [20]

C

38/66

36.5

Howell [14]

C

15/40

27.3

Pelizzo [35]

C

98/43

69.5

McKelvie [68]

C

45/22

67.2

Riesco [37]

C

28/39

41.8

Ito [23]

C

38/64

37.3

Russo [60]

C

57/46

55.3

Ulisse [45]

C

44/47

48.4

Sykorova [63]

C

81/161

33.5

Musholt [46]

C

122/168

42.1

Angell [53]

C

16/17

48.9

Xing [18]

C

107/112

48.9

Xing [19]

C

73/117

40.6

Xing [52]

C

194/313

38.3

Xing [1, 10]

C/A

845/1004

45.7