Skip to main content

Table 2 Comparative studies of survival following AR versus NAR in HCC patients with cirrhosis

From: Severity of liver cirrhosis: a key role in the selection of surgical modality for Child-Pugh A hepatocellular carcinoma

Authors

Type of resection

Patients ( n )

Cirrhosis (%)

5-year survival (%)

P value

Hasegawa et al. [59]

AR

156

32.1

66.0

0.01

 

NAR

54

57.4

35.0

 

Kaibori et al. [65]

AR

34

29.4

53.7

0.717

 

NAR

213

54.0

52.5

 

Wakai et al. [61]

AR

95

46.3

67.0

0.036

 

NAR

63

66.7

59.0

 

Yamashita et al. [64]

AR

201

48.8

76.0

NS

 

NAR

120

68.3

74.0

 

Ueno et al. [67]

AR

52

51.9

63.0

0.19

 

NAR

64

67.2

58.0

 

Eguchi et al. [60]

AR

2267

NA

65.5

0.053

 

NAR

3514

NA

62.4

 

Tanaka et al. [66]

AR

83

38.6

54.0

0.34

 

NAR

42

52.4

61.0

 

Nanashima et al. [68]

AR

49

38.8

55.0

NS

 

NAR

64

42.2

66.0

 

Kamiyama et al. [63]

AR

152

23.7

83.0

<0.001

 

NAR

133

47.4

65.3

 

Kang et al. [69]

AR

146

54.8

48.0

0.762

 

NAR

21

76.2

40.0

 
  1. AR, anatomic resection; NAR, non-anatomic resection; NA, not available; NS, not significant.