Table 5 Comparison of the validity of Tokuhashi and Tomita scores

Tokuhashi

Original

1

12-15

12

37.1 (18.9 - 55.3)

17.1 (5.9 - 28.2)

-

0.000

2

9-11

21

32.8 (18.6 - 47.0)

10.7 (9.1 - 12.3)

1.23

0.654

3

0-8

79

9.4 (6.6 - 12.3)

5.3 (4.4 - 6.1)

3.17

0.004

Adjusted

1

12-15

14

38.3 (21.6 - 54.9)

17.1 (5.0 - 29.1)

-

0.000

2

9-11

27

26.9 (15.1 - 38.8)

8.9 (3.0 - 14.8)

1.67

0.222

3

0-8

71

9.0 (6.1 - 11.9)

4.9 (4.1 - 5.6)

3.56

0.001

Regrouped

1^*

10-15

31

36.5 (24.9 - 48.1)

14.9 (5.3 - 24.5)

-

0.000

2^*

6-9

47

12.9 (8.4 - 17.3)

6.2 (4.6 - 7.8)

2.42

0.002

3^*

0-5

34

4.4 (3.3 - 5.5)

3.9 (2.1 - 5.8)

6.17

0.000

Tomita

Original

1

2-3

12

53.6 (36.3 - 70.8)

N/A

-

0.000

2

4-5

31

27.0 (16.2 - 37.8)

10.0 (7.7 - 12.4)

3.30

0.028

3

6-7

40

9.0 (5.7 - 12.4)

5.3 (4.4 - 6.1)

6.96

0.000

4

8-10

29

4.6 (3.2 - 6.0)

3.3 (2.2 - 4.5)

12.65

0.000

Regrouped

1^*

2-3

12

53.6 (36.3 - 70.8)

N/A

-

0.000

2^*

4-5

31

27.0 (16.2 - 37.8)

10.0 (7.7 - 12.4)

3.33

0.027

3^*

6-8

57

8.2 (5.7 - 10.6)

5.5 (4.5 - 6.5)

7.65

0.000

4^*

9-10

12

2.4 (1.7 - 3.1)

2.3 (1.7 - 2.9)

42.62

0.000