Wang JW 2005[11]
|
486
|
140/346
|
18-75
|
SCC (129) LAC (165) Others (28)
|
IIIA (51) IIIB (81) IV (185)
|
ECGO
|
NPE versus NP + placebo
|
322
|
164
|
RR, DCR, TTP, SI, AEs
|
Yang L 2005[12]
|
87
|
28/59
|
37-76
|
SCC (34) LAC (50) Others (3)
|
III (32) IV (55)
|
ECGO
|
NPE versus NP
|
57
|
33
|
RR, DCR, SI, AEs
|
Cai L 2007[13]
|
71
|
25/46
|
NA
|
SCC (27) LAC (32) Others (12)
|
IIIA (9) IIIB (33) IV (29)
|
KPS
|
NPE versus NP
|
39
|
32
|
RR, DCR, AEs
|
Mu HY 2009[14]
|
62
|
22/40
|
42-75
|
SCC (28) LAC (34)
|
IIIB (28) IV (34)
|
KPS
|
NPE versus NP (16) TPE versus TP (6) PPE versus PP (8)
|
32
|
30
|
RR, DCR, SI, AEs
|
Liao HY 2009[15]
|
85
|
32/53
|
36-72
|
SCC (36) LAC (49)
|
IIIB (32) IV (53)
|
KPS
|
GPE versus GP
|
30
|
55
|
RR, DCR, OYS, AEs
|
Zang T 2009[16]
|
104
|
36/68
|
42-68
|
NA
|
IIIB (58) IV (46)
|
ECGO
|
GPE versus GP
|
48
|
56
|
RR, DCR, SI, AEs
|
Liu J 2009[17]
|
62
|
17/45
|
29-68
|
SCC (38) LAC (24)
|
III (37) IV (25)
|
KPS
|
NPE + RT versus NP + RT
|
31
|
31
|
RR, DCR, TTP, AEs
|
Ma JB 2009[18]
|
46
|
11/35
|
38-73
|
SCC (31) LAC (15)
|
IIIA (26) IIIB (20)
|
ECGO
|
NPE + RT versus NP + RT
|
23
|
23
|
RR, DCR, TTP, AEs
|
Shi GY 2009[19]
|
462
|
162/300
|
20-74
|
SCC (190) LAC (252) Others (20)
|
IIIA (92) IIIB (144) IV (226)
|
ECGO
|
GPE versus GP
|
308
|
154
|
RR, DCR, TTP, SI, AEs
|
Han BH 2011[20]
|
122
|
35/87
|
28-78
|
SCC (37) LAC (78) Others (7)
|
IIIB (43) IV (79)
|
ECGO
|
TCE versus TC + placebo
|
61
|
61
|
RR, DCR, AEs
|
Zhao X 2011[21]
|
69
|
23/46
|
35-73
|
SCC (34) LAC (25) Others(10)
|
IIIB (11) IV (58)
|
ECGO
|
GPE versus GP
|
33
|
36
|
RR, DCR, AEs
|
Hu HT 2011[22]
|
89
|
21/68
|
41-70
|
SCLC (89)
|
NA
|
KPS
|
TPE versus TP
|
45
|
44
|
RR, DCR, AEs
|
Wen F 2011[23]
|
84
|
27/57
|
54-75
|
SCC (36) LAC (44) Others (4)
|
NA
|
KPS
|
NPE versus NP
|
43
|
41
|
RR, DCR, AEs
|
Zhang H 2011[24]
|
56
|
15/41
|
36-75
|
SCC (18) LAC (33) Others (5)
|
IIIB (32) IV (25)
|
KPS
|
NPE versus NP (2) GPE versus GP (15) TPE versus TP (11)
|
28
|
28
|
RR, DCR, TTP, OYS, AEs
|
Chen Q 2011[25]
|
68
|
27/41
|
42-75
|
SCC (20) LAC (44) Others (4)
|
IIIA (15) IIIB (41) IV (12)
|
NA
|
GPE versus GP
|
33
|
35
|
RR, DCR, SI
|