Meta-analysis of clinical efficacy of thoracoscopy and robotic surgery in the treatment of mediastinal tumors

Dang, Jiying; Sun, Shize; Wu, Zhengqi; Shan, Yidong; Zhang, Huiling

doi:10.1186/s12957-024-03325-5

World Journal of Surgical Oncology

Table 1 Basic information about the included studies

From: Meta-analysis of clinical efficacy of thoracoscopy and robotic surgery in the treatment of mediastinal tumors

First author, Year	Study date	Country	Group	Patients	Male/female	Age (years)	NOS score
Jens 2011 [9]	1994–2006	USA	RATS	74	32/42	39(7–75)	8
Jens 2011 [9]			VATS	79	23/56	37(11–74)
Ye 2013 [10]	2009–2012	China	RATS	21	13/12	53.4 ± 5.4	7
Ye 2013 [10]			VATS	25	9/12	52.7 ± 7.8
Yi 2014 [11]	2009–2012	China	RATS	55	25/30	41.4(16–65)	8
Yi 2014 [11]			VATS	60	30/30	43.5(18–66)
Rowse 2015 [12]	1995–2015	USA	RATS	11	6/5	52.2(23–74)	8
Rowse 2015 [12]			VATS	45	19/26	50.6(23–87)
Suda 2016 [13]	2011–2015	Japan	RATS	7	4/3	55.5 ± 9.9	8
Suda 2016 [13]			VATS	18	12/6	53.4 ± 14.8
Qian 2017 [14]	2009–2014	China	RATS	51	21/30	48.8 ± 13.3	7
Qian 2017 [14]			VATS	35	19/16	50.3 ± 13.1
Kamel 2019 [15]	2010–2014	USA	RATS	300	51/249	63	7
Kamel 2019 [15]			VATS	280	50/230	62
Abidin 2020 [16]	2010–2018	USA	RATS	21	13/8	41.29 ± 7.05	8
Abidin 2020 [16]			VATS	24	14/10	42.52 ± 7.45
Yang 2020 [17]	2010–2014	USA	RATS	77	31/46	60.9 ± 10.7	7
Yang 2020 [17]			VATS	77	32/45	61.1 ± 12.2
Li 2020 [18]	2009–2014	China	RATS	60	30/30	53.72 ± 13.11	7
Li 2020 [18]			VATS	60	30/30	51.22 ± 12.21
Ali 2021 [19]	2006–2019	Denmark	RATS	39	32/7	58(20.5)	8
Ali 2021 [19]			VATS	13	9/4	68(13.0)
Raja 2021 [20]	2009 ~ 2019	USA	RATS	380	154/226	43.2 ± 16.7	8
Raja 2021 [20]			VATS	340	129/211	40.6 ± 16.8
Imielski 2021 [21]	2007 ~ 2017	USA	RATS	54	29/25	44.9 ± 15.8	8
Imielski 2021 [21]			VATS	97	42/55	47.4 ± 15.2
Salfity 2021 [22]	2010 ~ 2015	USA	RATS	325	151/174	63(22 ~ 90)	7
Salfity 2021 [22]			VATS	263	120/143	64(20 ~ 88)
Chiba 2022 [23]	2011 ~ 2021	Japan	RATS	20	7/13	55(34 ~ 88)	7
Chiba 2022 [23]			VATS	37	16/21	61(30 ~ 82)
Li 2022 [24]	2018 ~ 2021	China	RATS	106	45/61	46(34 ~ 57)	8
Li 2022 [24]			VATS	106	45/61	48(40 ~ 56)
Jiang 2022 [25]	2016 ~ 2022	China	RATS	61	40/21	46.10 ± 14.10	7
Jiang 2022 [25]			VATS	36	19/17	47.60 ± 14.60
Hong 2023 [26]	2014 ~ 2022	China	RATS	34	14/20	41.03 ± 7.38	8
Hong 2023 [26]			VATS	36	17/19	43.06 ± 6.82
Ochi 2023 [27]	2014 ~ 2022	Japan	RATS	46	28/18	67(28 ~ 78)	8
Ochi 2023 [27]			VATS	144	84/60	52.5(10 ~ 83)

Back to article page

ISSN: 1477-7819

Contact us

General enquiries: journalsubmissions@springernature.com